The Pinball Effect: When a Day in your Program Feels Like a Game You Can’t Win
You’ve probably had days like I had.
A random Tuesday in program where I’m hunting a lost permission slip, de-escalating a heated argument over a TikTok challenge, and figuring out why the gym is suddenly unavailable for our programming – all minutes after I walked through the door. Sometimes running your program feels like a game of pinball, and you’re the pinball. One minute you’re chill, the next you’re being launched into a world of unpredictable bumpers, flashing lights, and unexpected obstacles - bouncing from one crisis to the next. What’s worse, it all feels like it’s being done to you, some unexplained invisible hand bent on making this tough for you. It doesn’t have to be that way, and the first step is realizing you’re in the game at all.
The Pinball Experience in Youth Programs
No matter your position, you have probably had those “pinball moments” happen to you:
Constantly changing directive from administration, the board, or your boss
Unpredictable student (or even staffing) attendance and engagement
Resources you thought you had suddenly gone
Last minute schedule changes and unexpected space issues
Responding to intense behavior incidents
If you’re unfamiliar with a pinball game, it’s an arcade game that has a metal ball players propel across an angled, obstacle-filled playfield. Players use flippers at the bottom of the playfield to prevent the ball from going “out” and to try to hit the ball towards targets, bumpers, and ramps. There’s a bit of skill – you’re trying to rack up as many points and trying to focus in a game that likely has a bit of theming, a ton of lighting, digital displays, and surprises. From the point of view of the metal ball, it’s just zipping around hitting random things without any thought – sound like moments you’ve had in your program?
Why We Experience the Pinball Effect
No matter how random that pinball experience in your program can feel, it really isn’t – it reflects system blindness (in particular, spatial blindness) that prevents us from seeing the larger pattens at work.
Different Worlds, Same Space
In an OST (out-of-school) time setting like an afterschool program or summer camp, you’re likely juggling multiple “worlds” simultaneously. The school administration might see your program as an extension of their school day. Families view it as childcare with a bit of enrichment. Kids see it as freedom with few rules. Funders and donors expect measurable outcomes. You’re trying to deliver high quality programming. These worlds collide daily, creating those pinball moments.
The Invisible Context
When you suddenly need to give up your space to someone else, a staff member is sick and can’t work, or a kid has a meltdown, these aren’t isolated incidents. They’re pieces of a complex system that has limited resources, competing priorities, and communication channels that are not always clear.
The Missing History
Most “pinball moments” have some sort of precedent. That surprise assembly? Actually happens every year. Staffing shortage? Predictable ebb and flow of the season. Without seeing the historical patterns, each crisis feels new and chaotic.
Relational Blind Spots
The relationships between staff (teachers and OST staff in an afterschool program, leadership and line staff in a summer camp) form a web that impacts daily operations. We can’t always see how these relationships interact and we experience their effects as unpredictable bumpers in our path. This goes for families too, who just want what they deem best for their kid but we see as a new imposition.
I’ve had those weeks where it felt like everything was falling apart. Daily schedule changes, spikes in behavioral issues, and supplies that didn’t arrive or went missing. It wasn’t until we started looking for the patterns did we see that often what felt like random chaos actually had a triggers we could change. We moved from the spatial blindness of the pinball game to spatial sight.
Moving from Pinball to Purpose
We can sometimes be quick to blame a specific person rather than look at the system. However, seeing the system transforms your experience from helpless pinball to purposeful participant. Here are ways to make that shift, and in the next section I’ll give a few more practical suggestions beyond theory.
Create a System Map
Gather your team and literally draw your ecosystem. Think big whiteboard or paper with multicolored markers. Who influences your work? What people or resources do you depend on? Where are the decision points each day, week, month, season? A visual representation helps everyone see connections that were previously hidden.
Track Patterns over Time
Start documenting those “random” disruptions. You might find a pattern – certain days of the week, times of the years, or after triggering events. When I ran an after-school program I saw that behavior incidents spiked every Wednesday. The cause? Early dismissal at a neighboring school brought disruptive older siblings to our pickup area.
Identify Your Control Points
In every system, there are points that you can leverage where a small change can have a big effect. Maybe adjust your schedule by 15 minutes, create a new communications protocol, or add rituals for how you transition between activities.
Shift Your Narrative
The most powerful change is in you (so cheesy but so true, right?). When you understand that the “pinball bumpers” are predictable parts of a system, not random chaos, you approach challenges differently. Instead of thinking “why does this always happen to me?” you ask “What’s triggering this pattern, and how can we adapt?”
When we started teaching about systems at Camp Timberlake, my staff transformed how they approached problems. Rather than just reacting and blaming the mysterious “they,” my staff could anticipate patterns and look to address the root causes. The chaos didn’t completely disappear – we do work with kids, after all- but how we felt about it fundamentally changed.
Practical Applications for OST Leaders
Moving from theory to practice, here are some specific strategies leaders can implement to transform the pinball experience.
Structured Huddles
Start and end each day with a brief, intentional team huddle. Morning huddles preview anticipated challenges and assign roles; afternoon huddles reflect on patterns and prepare for tomorrow. These moments, when done right, highlight the system and show the connections. When you keep doing this, you build that muscle in your staff.
Design Visual Workflow Maps
Create visual representations of your most common processes – from check-in procedures to behavior management protocols. Make boxes for who does what and arrows to show steps in the process. These visual guides help staff navigate systems and reveal bottlenecks or redundancies. One program I worked with mapped their arrival process and realized three separate staff were collection similar information from families.
Intentionally Teach About Systems
Ensure your staff understand how their role connects to others, the impacts they have on each other, and the hidden parts of the job each other doesn’t see. When the arts specialist understands the constraints of the administrative team and when the site coordinator knows the challenges of front-line staff, communication improves and blame decreases.
Create TOOTs (Time Out Of Time)
It’s a funny name to describe a profound habit: schedule regular opportunities for the entire team to step back and share their experiences. Unlike a typical staff meeting devoted to logistics, these center on perception-sharing: “What is your world like? What pressures are you experiencing? How do you see other parts of our program?” Do this at least quarterly.
Develop Feedback Loops
Establish routine ways to collect insights from all stakeholders quickly and efficiently. Simple tools like a plus/delta (what went well/what could change) evaluations after activities can identify emerging patterns before they become problems. At the end of each summer we did an activity where each activity area had a bit sheet with those simple tools. Allowed us to evaluate the entire program in about an hour and ensure folks had their voices heard.
When I’ve seen these practices implemented in programs, the transformation isn’t just operational – it’s cultural. Staff move from feeling victimized by circumstances (trapped in a pinball machine) to seeing themselves as active members of the system.
Concluding Thoughts
What if that feeling of being bounced around isn't inevitable? What if, with a shift in perspective, you could see the patterns, understand the connections, and transform your experience from pinball to purpose? Seeing systems doesn’t solve everything – but it does take big steps to do so. When you start to see the system the bells and whistles don’t stop (there are always curveballs and surprises) but you’re no longer just a ball ricocheting around the machine. You can influence the game and have a sense of agency. You can win this game!
You should look to identify one “pinball pattern” in your program and look for the system behind it. You can ask a few questions when you feel like a pinball:
What seemingly random events keep recurring in my program?
Who else is impacted by these events, and how are they responding?
What larger organizational patterns might explain these recurring situations?
Keeping follow us as we dive even deeper into the dynamics and find out how you can improve your program.
We’re here to help you through this. Feel free to reach out to us with your questions and follow us on LinkedIn, Instagram, and Pinterest! We’ll be able to help you solve your problems.
Interested in working with us? Sign up for a free 30-minute call to assess your systems and see how we can help.
